Too-Cute Turkey Cookies Make your cookies in advance and set the table with frosting and sweet decorations: peanut butter cups, mini M&Ms®, vanilla wafers and sprinkles galore! Get the Recipe Fox-Faced Pie Halved fig-flavored Newtons cookies make alert ears on top of your classic Pumpkin Pie. Let the kids decorate their slices with a whipped cream mask and chocolate candy eyes and nose. Turkey-Faced Pie Mini Oreo® cookies plus M&Ms® make a fun googly-eyed turkey face for pumpkin pie. Finish it with a fancy candy corn tail and Newton nose.