We’ve tested several of our pot pies to see how they fare in the freezer, and have found two methods we like best. For best results, use within 1 to 2 months of freeze date.
Method 1: For Full-Size Pot Pies
For full-size pot pies, like our Classic Chicken Pot Pie, we found that you get the best results if you prepare and freeze just the filling in advance, vs. the entire pot pie. We tested baking, freezing and reheating a complete pot pie, but found that by the time all the filling had heated through, the crust tasted overdone after essentially baking twice. We think our method of preparing and freezing the filling separately gives you the best of both worlds: You’ll save time and effort by skipping a few steps the day of making, and you’ll still get to enjoy a perfectly golden, flaky crust.
To freeze pot pie filling: Prepare as directed in recipe. Cool uncovered in refrigerator 30 minutes. Spoon mixture into 1-gallon freezer food storage plastic bag, leaving 1/2 to 1 inch at top of bag for expansion; seal. Freeze up to 1 month. To bake, thaw mixture overnight in refrigerator. Pour into 2-quart saucepan, heat over medium heat, 5 to 6 minutes, stirring frequently until thoroughly heated. Assemble, fill and bake pie as directed in recipe.
Method 2: For Mini Pot Pies
For a true heat-and-eat recipe—and maximum convenience—mini pot pies are the perfect option. Unlike full-size pot pies, mini pot pies should be cooked completely before being frozen; their small size means they’ll heat through quickly without compromising the flavor or texture of the crust.
To freeze mini pot pies: After placing unbaked pies in muffin cups, wrap muffin pan in foil and freeze completely, about 2 hours. Once pies are frozen, run knife around edge of pan to loosen; remove from muffin tin. Wrap each in plastic wrap, and place frozen pies in large resealable freezer plastic bag.